WHAT MAKES A BAD BAND?

I want technical reasons please...not like..."They're populer"

Usually it's cause they try too hard to be/play something they are not/they can't.

And sometimes, they just suck

a band that does only cover songs and nothing original. Lack of creativity.

Music sucks when it's not art. If you just copy any other band or make music with a commercial purpose, then it's not art.
Music is expressing your feelings. Music is a way to translate your feelings, your emotions and your personal view of the world in an universal language.

yea, its already been said... lack of creativity.

when there music is more like noise, when the instruments play something that doesn't fit with the other instruments

this is kind of off topic but not. I hate musicians (and celebrities) who are activists and oppose this issue or that issue. If you want to send a message put it in your music, I don't want to see you at an awards show denouncing bush or the war. You are just a single person like everyone else and your opinion means just as much as anyone's so shut the fock up already.

ha, i thought this thread was about what makes a band bad.. as in a bad boy/girl appreance.. oops

"What makes a bad band?"

bad songs and/or bad players. thats it.

that's it? come on, you can elaborate on that a bit more, because you seem to always have something negative to say.