Quote:
|
Originally Posted by ffreeloader
Thank very much Satch and Roivas. This will make me busy for a while. I'll start off with Beethoven 9th and Dvorak 9th.
I am curious now, Roivas you are saying that the performer is very important . In what way? Does every performer add like a certain style, or changes part of the sonwriting or something? or it has to do with the instruments they use? I really have no idea on this.
Thanx again, and as soon as I start listening to something I will let you know what I think.
|
In
classical music the
conductors,
musicians,
vocalists are important.
Keep in mind most of the
composers have been dead
for a long time. All there is their manuscripts with directions like
Allegro, Adagio, Forte, Fortepiano, Presto, Pianissimo, etc....written on the manuscripts.
How that is interpreted is decided by the conductors of a
Symphony....and the quality of the music is going to determined by how well the
musicians/
vocalists perform.
A conductor may choose to play a
Symphony quickly on one occasion and slower on the next. Depending on the conductor and performers this may work or may not. Which is why fans of
Classical will have multiple recordings of compositions they like.
For example, above I gave you two links of recordings for
Beethoven's 9th which I enjoy.
How well any genre music sounds depends on those performing it....just like how it sounds depends on how they play it.
In
Rock terms....for the quality comparison...
Voodoo Child (Slight Return) has been covered many times. No two versions sound the same and some are good and some are good....and none of them sound like
Hendrix's original, or are anywhere as good.
It's no different in
Jazz....take any
Jazz standard and you will a great many ways it will sound and performed.