Yeah, there are so many factors that can influence sound and how you feel about an amp. First...as mpittman said...you have to hear your own guitar through it to find out if it's compatible. I tried one guitar through an amp and it sounded fine then tried a different guitar and it really sounded like crap...not that the guitar was a hunk of junk but sometimes equipment is 'just not right for each other'.
Like panbient said...your needs will be different if you plan on gigging than if you don't. Furthermore it may be better to start off small with a practice amp because if your needs change and you require something bigger later on then you will still have the practice amp when you get a big amp which will save you from using the big one every time you want to play. Imagine the Marshall half stack in the bedroom...not that there's anything wrong with that!!
You may also find that years down the road something that was fine for you in the beginning sounds like crap just due to your familiarity with guitar and music.
I have had an 80's Traynor, Crate, KMD, Marshall in the past and they truly have all had strengths.
The 80's Traynor (Bloc100) was a great amp for cleans...but its own gain or overdrive was terrible...so a good distortion pedal sounded excellent through it.
The Crate was a nice amp...60 watts and a really nice distortion 'contour' control...dialed in anything from classic rock to metallica and beyond. I actually ended up using that one for vocals in a jam room. It worked perfectly!!
The Marshall (Master Reverb 30) is a nice little amp...I still have it. It is only a single channel but it sounds great and is near perfect for studio work. If it were a tube amp it would be perfect.
The KMD 100 watt I still own as well but it is currently lent to someone. It is in the same world as the 80's Traynor actually in that it doesn't have good distortion but has a nice clean sound...therefor...great for a nice distortion pedal...and huge on the power too...
I currently have an all tube Traynor YCV-40WR. It's one of the 'new' Traynors and I've only had it for 6 months. It is in a different world alltogether. Tube is so much different from solid state...but there is always the wear and tear to think about with tube amps.
I think the big problem for you will be that there is SO much on the market today that you won't know what to buy. It's a tough decision so that's why I recommend the small practice amp first...depending on your budget of course maybe the VOX AD30VT would be the one for you...it's got some 'modelling' options to be able to cover a wide range of sounds and is still small enough to use as a practice amp yet large enough that you could mic it if you needed to use it for a gig before you upgraded.
Here is a link:
http://www.sweetwater.com/store/detail/AD30VT