Musicians and songwriters matter to me too much; I will happily listen to an album of good songs with horrible production values. I don't know if I would ever checkout a band or project based on the producer, if that producer was not already known to me from his or her time as a musician.
I can't even forsee a time when that would be desirable, although I have to admit, with Terry Date launching careers of many a wannabe, I often thought that eventually albums would be crediting the producer first and group of musicians involved on page 2 or 3 of the liner notes.
Given much of the popular music that's come out since, I think that's still a possibility
