Which of these two excellent Modest Mouse albums is your favorite? Personally i think The Moon and Antartica is their masterpeice, but im sure some will disagree.

i'm with you on this one! but i won't vote because i am a lazy bastard.

I prefer Good News, but I like The Moon and Antarctica as well. This band is quickly becoming one of my favorites.

moon & antarctica was the first mm record i ever heard--i think it will always be my favorite

Wilson mentioned in the last Modest Mouse thread that no one really voted in this thread... so instead of replying to that one here I am

I like The Moon and Antartica better. My favorite Modest Mouse album. Good news is great, but the Moon is definately shooting higher.

some indirect thread promoting never hurts. Way to notice suz

I love Good New.........News. I think it is a much better album than it's predicesors.

I'm glad that Modest Mouse is finally getting it's acclaim.

Moon and Antarctica by far... I would say Moon and Antarctica is tied w/ Lonesome Crowded West and Building Nothing out of Something as my fav 3 (as in 3 way tie) MM albums.